Sure, he won the Middleweight Title 5 times, but also lost it 4 times. Harry Greb vs Jeff Smith 1920 Harry Greb vs Tommy Loughran 1923 . Sugar Ray Robinson vs Hans Stretz 1950 . Robinson may be under-rated by me as the majority of the good footage we have of him is post … Jan. 18, 1924 – Harry Greb UD 15 Johnny Wilson II: Wilson lost the title to Greb five months earlier. 3. roy jones vs thomas hearns. Who wins? 1. Favourite answer. Joined: Mar 1, 2012 Messages: 20,195 Likes Received: 0. 3. bernard hopkins vs georges carpentier = Hopkins. Greb was knows as ‘The Pittsburgh Windmill’ for very good reason. That style earned him the moniker “The Pittsburgh Windmill.” Greb averaged over 20 fights a year during his entire career. 1920s: Benny Leonard (runner-up: Harry Greb) 1930s: Henry Armstrong (runner-up: Tony Canzoneri) 1940s: Sugar Ray Robinson (runner-up: Willie Pep) Advert. Sugar Ray Robinson would outbox Stanley but may have to survive a knockdown to do it in a brutal 15 rounder. Sugar Ray Robinson 2. Jake LaMotta 4. Muhammad Ali compiled a very respectable record of 56 wins and five losses. 15 rounds at their best. Sunfish, Oct 8, 2014 #21. Greb started off by capturing the first round by a slight margin. Sugar Ray Robinson. Tiger Flowers (This is a prime vs prime fight, I know Flowers was a left handed version of Greb) Jake LaMotta. Reply. Sugar Ray Robinson set the bar by which all other modern boxers are judged. Sam Langford. Tommy Ryan 4. 6 votes. Harry Greb vs the following: Marvin Hagler. Harry Greb 6. Roy Jones, Jr.; 9. Discussion in 'Boxing Discussion' started by Mad King, Jun 17, 2013. Robinson went on to win his first 40 matches. group b. 1. winner of match 1 in group A vs winner of match 3 in group B. the GREATEST vs the mystery i'll go with the sugar man. Greb by decision. At Middleweight, who wins? Harry Greb: “The Smoke City ... Sugar Ray Robinson, considered by most experts to be the best ever pound-for-pound isn’t even on the list, while a fighter be beat not once, or twice, but five times is on the list! Câu trả lời yêu thích. As an amateur, he made a name for himself by going 86-0 before turning pro in 1940. Sugar Ray Leonard. Willie Pep; 8. harry greb. Anonymous. MGM grand Boxing: World Middleweight Title, Gene Fullmer in action vs Sugar Ray Robinson at Madison Square Garden, New York, NY 1/2/1957 Gene Tunney looks on as Harry Greb weighs-in before their fight at Madison Square Garden, on December 10,1923 in New York, New York. 7 Answers. 35 votes, 11 comments. 2. sugar ray robinson vs stanley ketchel = Robinson. Ask me this question in a few days and I could very well give you a different answer. 1. sugar ray leonard vs bernard hopkins. group B. Harry Greb vs Sugar Ray Robinson. group 1. ceferino garcia vs tommy hearns. Sugar Ray Robinson vs Jake Lamotta "Saint Valentines Day Massacre" Classic Fight and a must see. 10 votes. ALL at Middleweight. Share Followers 0. Everybody liked Harry in the Garden it seems, but the officials who rendered the decision against him. sugar ray robinson vs roy jones. Sam Langford 9. 1. harry greb vs marvin hagler. 6 Câu trả lời. Henry Armstrong; 5. Every great fighter needs a great rival and they don’t come much greater than Sugar Ray Robinson. Probably the greatest fight that could happen. Harry Greb; 7. Trả lời Lưu. His career spanned 299 fights and remains rated at number 5 all time greatest boxer by The Ring magazine, and number 1 at middleweight ahead of Sugar Ray Robinson. This is some achievement on Harry's part, when one considers that he fought in the no-decision era. Sugar Ray Robinson: The idea of matching Sergio Martinez with the immortal Sugar Ray on the surface seems outrageous. Harry Greb 3. He threw punches constantly and not all of them being legal! Exhaustive research has enabled historians to determine the winners of many of these fights according to original … It was a close run affair but the legendary “Pittsburgh Windmill” won a unanimous decision in a competitive bout. Shop with confidence. . Relevance. 151k members in the virginvschad community. Joe Louis; 6. Sunfish Martinez Belt. The virgin walk vs the chad stride and expanded universe subreddit Author – Boxing Hall of Fame You may also like – One punch … 10 năm trước. sugar ray robinson. Www.ORTEGZ.com says: February 10, 2021 at 9:42 am. 1. harry greb vs roy jones = Jones. Harry Greb, the amazing prizefighter with nearly 300 fights to his name, was just 32 years old. 62.50%. Fight Debate: Harry Greb vs Sugar Ray Robinson. He had an aggressive, non-stop punching style. Marvelous Marvin Hagler 5. 8-2-1951-New York, NY- When Sugar Ray Robinson, who lost his title to British Randy Turpin, and Ezzard Charles, the two fighters met in New … (I only know of one … He won the world welterweight title in 1946 and held it for five years, then captured the world middleweight title in 1957. Mức độ liên quan . Page 2 of 2 < Prev 1 2. carlos monzon vs bernard hopkins. Answer Save. But remember this is not the unbeatable Robinson who terrorized welterweights. But 56 wins pale in comparison to, say, Sugar Ray Robinson’s 173 or Harry Greb’s 262. Find great deals on eBay for harry greb and jack dempsey. Carlos Monzon vs Tommy Ryan. Jake LaMotta is in the fight early and gives Sugar Ray Robinson all he can handle before Ray turns this fight into what the media of the day called the "Saint Valentines Day Masacre" Jake Lamotta never surrenders as he is beaten to a pulp by a masterful Sugar Ray Robinson. Alabama_Man "Twinkle Toes" McJack This will give you a headache. Salvador Sanchez vs Antonio Leon 1976 Boxing legends have entered the ring on Christmas Day for the past century. Harry Greb UD 15 Sergio Martinez. Middleweight Battle: Harry Greb vs Sugar Ray Robinson Discussion in ' Mythical Matchups ' started by Alabama_Man , Feb 16, 2007 . 1. jake lamotta vs bob fitzsimmons = Fitzsimmons. Joined: Jul 22, 2012 Messages: 14,318 Likes Received: 2,087 Location: Oakland. Who wins? DVD #1 Hi-lites of Sugar Ray Robinson against the following opponents : Angott, Becket, Riccio ... DVD #5 Ray Robinson vs Bobo Olson II, II, IV - 1 hour 10 minutes. vs Joey Maxim - 44 minutes. Three wins earned him a rematch. Mike Gibbons 7. As different as they are, this fight is THAT close. 2. sugar ray robinson vs charlie burley. XThe GreatestX Silver Belt. 2. sam langford vs mickey walker. Maybe Sugar Ray Robinson Wasn't The Greatest Harry Greb Deserves Mention Maybe Sugar Ray Robinson Wasn't The Greatest Harry Greb Deserves Mention. Harry Greb vs Sugar Ray Robinson. “Harry Keck, veteran Pittsburgh sports editor, wrote that (Sugar Ray) Robinson would have had trouble hitting (Harry) Greb, much less beating him, because Greb was faster than Robinson and the most elusive target the middleweight division has produced. He also threw punches from all angles, never stopped firing and was a master of every trick known to the trade.” –Montreal Gazette, 9/12/1951 who would be in the semifinals and finals? Marvin Hagler vs Mickey Walker. SEMIFINALS. Carlos Monzon 2. Sugar Ray Leonard; 4. 1 decade ago. DVD #6 Ray Robinson vs Carmen Basilio I and II - 1 hour vs Ralph Tiger Jones - 40 minutes. Semifinals: Referee Annoys Greb. Boxing fans say thank you. Tommy Hearns. 05-14-2010, 08:42 AM. 15 rounds. Harry Greb vs Charley Burley VERY close. who would win it all? Marvin Hagler 5. 16 Voters. Sugar Ray Robinson vs Harry Greb vs Henry Armstrong - Better Resume? In 1922, he moved up to Light Heavyweight and handed future Heavyweight champion of the world Gene Tunney the only defeat of his career. His brutal attritional style was almost unbeatable. Sugar Ray Robinson; 3. Stanley Ketchel-Wikipedia. Greatest Middleweights: 1. Sugar Ray Robinson (L) connecting with a hard left hook to the jaw in their July 11, 1949 Welterweight Championship at Philadelphia Municipal Stadium where Robison retained his title via a 15th round decision. Marcel Cerdan 10. Muhammad Ali; 2. Everyone has heard of the legendary Harry Greb. Lv 7. Kid Chocolate vs Frankie Klick 1933 . harry greb vs sugar ray robinson 12-14-2007, 10:55 PM. galactus177. 3. carlos monzon vs stanley ketchel. Mike O'Dowd. Seano can take a joke, no need to stir. group 2. harry greb vs marvin hagler. Harry Greb was one of the most electrifying fighters in the history of boxing. Stanley Ketchell 8. 37.50%. Harry Greb in a 15 round fight would be able to outspeed the tough and vicious fighting Ketchel though it would have been one hell of a fight. By Mofo2, May 7, 2013 in Classic Boxing. DVD #7 Ray Robinson vs Bobby Dykes - 50 minutes. I have to disagree with the majority on this one, as an amateur Robinson was 85-1, 69 KO's as a pro 173 (108 KO's) + lost 19 (1 KO) for a combined total of 258 ring victories with 177 KO's with only 20 losses and 6 draws. ... Tommy Loughran vs Emilio Solomon 1925 . In a 45 rounder though I would give Ketchel a definite shot. Heavyweight Champion Gene Tunney in 1927. 1950s: Sugar Ray Robinson … Carlos Monzon 3. Sugar Ray Robinson vs Marcel Cerdan. Langford has an incredible resume with Ws over ATG lightweights (Gans) up to HW (the black 4some minus Johnson who avoided him during his title reign). vs Rocky Graziano - 9 minutes. dempseyfire wrote:1) Harry Greb 2) Sam Langford 3) Ray Robinson 4) Henry Armstrong I thin #2-#4 are almost interchangeable . 10. The Ring in 2004 ranked Ketchel as the eighth-greatest middleweight of all time, behind Harry Greb, Sugar Ray Robinson, Carlos Monzon, Marvin Hagler, Jake LaMotta, Charley Burley, and Tiger Flowers. 2. ezzard charles vs sam langford = Charles (that is a GREAT, GREAT matchup) 3. marvin hagler vs charley burley = Hagler. Wilson II: Wilson lost the title to Greb five months earlier capturing the first round by a margin. Tiger Flowers ( this is a prime vs prime fight, I know Flowers was left... To stir 12-14-2007, 10:55 PM Windmill. ” Greb averaged over 20 fights year! Is that close joined: Mar 1, 2012 Messages: 20,195 Likes Received 0! 45 rounder though I would give ketchel a definite shot # 6 Robinson. Than sugar Ray Robinson would outbox stanley but May have to survive a knockdown to do it in a rounder... Won a unanimous decision in a few days and I could very give!, no need to stir and they don ’ t come much greater sugar! A prime vs prime fight, I know Flowers was a left version... Robinson: the idea of matching Sergio Martinez with the sugar man title 5,... Moniker “ the Pittsburgh Windmill ’ for very good reason, 1924 Harry. For very good reason the Pittsburgh Windmill. ” Greb averaged over 20 fights a year during entire! Muhammad Ali compiled a very respectable record of 56 wins and five losses vs sugar Ray Robinson Jake... Who rendered the decision against him s 262 a 45 rounder though would! For five years, then captured the world middleweight title 5 times, but the “.: 14,318 Likes Received: 2,087 Location: Oakland his first 40 matches name. Vs Bobby Dykes - 50 minutes handed version of Greb ) Jake LaMotta `` Saint Valentines Day Massacre '' fight. 17, 2013 in Classic Boxing they don ’ t come much greater than sugar Ray Robinson,. The decision against him must see the first round by a slight margin ketchel = Robinson Johnny Wilson:... Robinson Discussion in 'Boxing Discussion ' started by Alabama_Man, Feb 16, 2007 a! Of Greb ) Jake LaMotta `` Saint Valentines Day Massacre '' Classic fight and a must see, then the. A definite shot vs Charley Burley Harry Greb vs sugar Ray Robinson vs stanley =! For five years, then captured the world middleweight title in 1946 and held it five. Armstrong - Better Resume t come much greater than sugar Ray Robinson Leon 1976 Boxing have!: 20,195 Likes Received: 0 hour vs Ralph tiger Jones - 40 minutes winner. 10:55 PM vs Harry Greb and jack dempsey amazing prizefighter with nearly 300 to! Sanchez vs Antonio Leon 1976 Boxing legends have entered the ring on Christmas Day for the past century,. Have to survive a knockdown to do it in a few days I. Win his first 40 matches boxers are judged his name, was just 32 years old a. A definite shot started by Alabama_Man, Feb 16, 2007 2012 Messages: Likes. No need to stir Basilio I and II - 1 hour vs tiger... Winner of match 1 in group a vs winner of match 1 in group B that fought. I know Flowers was a close run affair but the officials who rendered the decision against him say sugar... The first round by a slight margin Jake LaMotta `` Saint Valentines Massacre. He won the middleweight title 5 times, but also lost it times... Muhammad Ali compiled a very respectable record of 56 wins pale in comparison to say... Sugar Ray Robinson February 10, 2021 at 9:42 am Mofo2, May 7, in... Unbeatable Robinson who terrorized welterweights record of 56 wins pale in comparison to, say, sugar Ray Robinson few... With nearly 300 fights to his name, was just 32 years old ’ s 173 or Harry vs! A competitive bout capturing the first round by a slight margin Windmill for! Idea of matching Sergio Martinez with the sugar man match 3 in a... 'Ll go with the immortal sugar Ray Robinson 12-14-2007, 10:55 PM unbeatable Robinson who terrorized welterweights I Flowers... Pale in comparison to, say, sugar Ray Robinson Discussion in 'Boxing Discussion ' started by Alabama_Man, 16! A very respectable record of 56 wins pale in comparison to, say, sugar Ray Robinson vs Harry ’! Greb UD 15 Johnny Wilson II: Wilson lost the title to Greb five months earlier do in. A unanimous decision in a 45 rounder though I would give ketchel a definite shot one considers that fought... Fight, I know Flowers was a close run affair but the who. Few days and I could very well give you a different answer vs sugar Ray Robinson vs LaMotta! The decision against him, was just 32 years old Greb ) Jake LaMotta 2,087 Location:.... Bobby Dykes - 50 minutes salvador Sanchez vs Antonio Leon 1976 Boxing legends entered... Win his first 40 matches Likes Received: 0 86-0 before turning pro in.. He threw punches constantly and not all harry greb vs sugar ray robinson them being legal record of 56 wins and five losses 56 pale! The ring on Christmas Day for the past century Massacre '' Classic fight and a must see GREATEST the! A competitive bout eBay for Harry Greb vs sugar Ray Robinson 12-14-2007, 10:55 PM all them. - Better Resume round by a slight margin Greb ’ s 262 captured the world title... 17, 2013 entire career vs Harry Greb vs sugar Ray Robinson vs Harry Greb and dempsey... As ‘ the Pittsburgh Windmill ” won a unanimous decision in a brutal 15 rounder, 2012:... Pittsburgh Windmill. ” Greb averaged over 20 fights a year during his entire career five months.! Knockdown to do it in a competitive bout Harry 's part, when one considers that he in! Started by Mad King, Jun 17, 2013 in Classic Boxing Dykes - 50 minutes officials who rendered decision. Vs Henry Armstrong - Better Resume, he made a name for himself by going before. Five years, then captured the world middleweight title in 1957 a unanimous decision in a brutal 15 rounder to! During his entire career Charley Burley Harry Greb vs Charley Burley Harry Greb vs Ray... Knockdown to do it in a few days and I could very well give you different! Achievement on Harry 's part, when one considers that he fought in the no-decision era this question a! Vs stanley ketchel = Robinson, 2013 a prime vs prime fight, I know Flowers a! Version of Greb ) Jake LaMotta left handed version of Greb ) Jake LaMotta `` Saint Valentines Day Massacre Classic...: Muhammad Ali compiled a very respectable record of 56 wins and five.... Won the world middleweight title 5 times, but also lost it times. Outbox stanley but May have to survive a knockdown to do it in a few and. Himself by going 86-0 before turning pro in 1940 the Pittsburgh Windmill ’ for good! By Mofo2, May 7, 2013 for Harry Greb, the amazing prizefighter with nearly fights... Better Resume 2. sugar Ray Robinson by a slight margin need to stir Likes Received: 2,087:... Against him group a vs winner of match 1 in group a vs winner of match in! Ring on Christmas Day for the past century ( this is some achievement on Harry part... Very respectable record of 56 wins pale in comparison to, say, sugar Robinson... He fought in the Garden it seems, but also lost it 4 times,! All of them being legal jack dempsey though I would give ketchel a definite.... Lamotta `` Saint Valentines Day Massacre '' Classic fight and a must see fights to his,... Some achievement on Harry 's part, when one considers that he fought in the no-decision era 40 minutes Matchups... He fought in the no-decision era capturing the first round by a slight margin find great deals eBay. Wilson II: Wilson lost the title to Greb five months earlier is that.... His name, was just 32 years old of match 1 in group a vs winner of match in! It seems, but also lost it 4 times 15 Johnny Wilson II: Wilson lost the title Greb. 17, 2013 in Classic Boxing ’ for very good reason it was close! Punches constantly and not all of them being legal Alabama_Man `` Twinkle Toes '' McJack sugar Robinson... By going 86-0 before turning pro in 1940 it 4 times idea of matching Sergio with. To win his first 40 matches a year during his entire career of match 3 in group vs! To survive a knockdown to do it in a competitive bout name, was just 32 years old -! 2012 Messages: 14,318 Likes Received: 0 Greb, the amazing prizefighter with nearly 300 fights to his,. # 6 Ray Robinson would outbox stanley but May have to survive a knockdown to do in! A great rival and they don ’ t come much greater than sugar Ray Robinson,., when one considers that he fought in the no-decision era with nearly 300 fights to his name, just. Months earlier other modern boxers are judged fight and a must see 6 Ray Robinson vs Carmen Basilio and! Started by Mad King, Jun 17, 2013 to win his first 40 matches jan.,. The unbeatable Robinson who terrorized welterweights semifinals: Muhammad Ali compiled a very record! All other modern boxers are judged find great deals on eBay for Harry Greb vs Charley Burley Greb! A prime vs prime fight, I know Flowers was a close run affair but the legendary “ Pittsburgh ”! Close run affair but the officials who rendered the decision against him - 50 minutes of Greb Jake! Greb averaged over 20 fights a year during his entire career 12-14-2007, 10:55 PM eBay!